Just bought the sergio steak, bowtie, pepper mafia and table 40 italian seasonings. Only had a chance so far to try the Sergio with a little added pepper mafia. Really good on filets at a family dinner - everyone loved it!!
The seasoning is good but the quantity was disappointing for the price. I get 4x more equivalent product from Bearded Butchers
Hi there, thank you for your feedback. We're sorry to hear that you were disappointed with the quantity of our Bowtie Seasoning. We strive to provide high-quality products at a fair price. We appreciate your suggestion and will take it into consideration for future improvements. Thank you for choosing our brand. Have a great day!
I ordered $96 of chicken and beef on the 4th of march 2025, and still have not received my order. This is the first and last time I order from this site!!!
Took my at home steak to another level. Literally it was all it needed, nothing else.
Thank you so much for your kind words about Sergio's Seasoning! We are thrilled to hear that it took your steak to the next level and was all you needed. We appreciate your support and hope you continue to enjoy our product. Happy seasoning!
I haven't used the Pepper Mafia yet, but I have used the pepper and salt mix which really does add to the flavor. I like these seasoning a lot. I gave a four because I closed the lid on the seasoning can and may have closed a little tight I guess. I tried to open the can again and it would not budge. I had to cut the can open and put the seasoning in a ziplock bag.That damn thing was welded Wow! I do appreciate these seasonings though so thanks
Thank you for your review and for trying out our Pepper Mafia seasoning. We're happy to hear that you enjoy the pepper and salt mix, and we apologize for the difficulty you had with the lid. We'll make sure to pass along your feedback to our team. We appreciate your support and hope you continue to enjoy our seasonings. Happy cooking!
Love it
Thank you for your positive feedback! We are delighted to hear that you love Sergio's Seasoning. It means a lot to us. Happy cooking!
The 308: A Seasoning Set
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review for our product, 'The 308: A Seasoning Set'. We are thrilled to hear that you are enjoying it. Thank you for your support and happy seasoning!
Great steaks ! Ready to try on everything…
Hi there! Thank you so much for trying out Sergio's Seasoning and leaving a review. We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed it on your steaks and are excited to see what other dishes you'll try it on. We appreciate your support and hope you continue to enjoy our seasoning. Happy cooking!
LOVE IT!!! I've enjoyed everything I've received so far and I tell everyone about it!
So yummy!
We love hearing that! Thank you for your support and for sharing the love—enjoy every delicious bite!
processed my order in first class fashion. can't wait to try recipes. made the gold fashion wife loved it
Hi there! Thank you for your review. We are so glad to hear that you had a positive experience with your first purchase and that you are excited to try out the recipes in our cookbook. We hope you and your wife enjoy the gold fashion recipe. Happy cooking!
Great! The best
Thank you! We're thrilled you love Sergio's Seasoning—it's truly something special!
Wish me would of tried it much sooner
Thank you so much for your kind words about Sergio's Seasoning! We are thrilled to hear that you love it, better late than never! We hope you continue to enjoy our product and thank you for being a valued customer.
Can't beat the flavors I'm getting !
Hi there! Thank you for leaving such a positive review for our Pepper Mafia Seasoning. We're thrilled to hear that you're enjoying the flavorful taste it adds to your dishes. We strive to provide our customers with the best possible flavors, and we're glad to know we hit the mark with you. Happy cooking!
Exactly as was stated. Very good!Yummy!
Glad to hear you enjoyed Sergio’s Seasoning! Thanks for your support—we appreciate you!
I previously wrote a review that was wrong, my mistake. I said I got a 2nd order that I didn't order, and wanted a refund. Actually, they were informed that I never got my order, so they sent a replacement. They called me to explain, and said I wasn't charged for the 2nd shipment. I'm so sorry for the mix up. That's great customer service to call and talk to me in person. I don't know how to delete the prior review, so I'm posting here to clarify that it was an error.
No worries at all! We truly appreciate your honesty and your kind words about our customer service. We're just happy we could get everything sorted out for you. If you ever need anything else, we're always here to help. Enjoy your seasonings!
I love this and use it on everything
Thank you for leaving such a wonderful review! We are so happy to hear that you love Sergio's Seasoning and use it on everything. It's always great to hear positive feedback from our customers. Thank you for your support and we hope you continue to enjoy our product.
As many rubs as I have, this is 100% my go to on anything beef anymore
Now that’s what we love to hear! Sergio’s Seasoning truly brings out the best in beef. Thanks for making it your go-to!
I make grilled cheese sandwiches this weekend using your product one word wow everyone love them thank you so much.
Hi there! Thank you for your review and for trying out our French Cuffs Seasoning. We're thrilled to hear that you and everyone else enjoyed your grilled cheese sandwiches with our product. That's what we love to hear! Keep on cooking and thank you for choosing French Cuffs Seasoning. Happy seasoning!
Your food & your entire staff are A #1.
Thank you so much for your kind words about our Maitre d’Butter Trio! We're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed it. We're also happy to know that our team at The Golden Steer made your dining experience exceptional. We appreciate your support and hope to see you again soon.
Excellent blend
Thank you for your kind words about our Pepper Mafia Seasoning! We are thrilled to hear that you enjoyed the blend. Your satisfaction is our top priority and we are grateful for your support. Thank you for choosing Pepper Mafia!
I cooked two thick-cut Ribeyes in my Gordon Ramsay Hexclad pan. I made sure the steak was at room temperature. Heat was at medium-high, and I added Sergio’s seasoning by drying the steak and sprinkling it on 30 minutes before cooking. I used grapeseen oil for cooking. I flipped both steaks both sides for four minutes each, let the fat render for a bit, then cooked them in the oven at 400 degrees Fahrenheit for two minutes each side. I basted them with garlic herb Irish butter. It was absolutely delicious!
Thank you for sharing your experience with Sergio's Seasoning! We are thrilled to hear that it added a delicious flavor to your Ribeyes. Your cooking method sounds perfect. Thanks for choosing our seasoning and happy cooking!
The seasoning is very tasty and I used it the first time on Tri-Tip. Only problem is the container was only 3/4 full, not what’s in the picture or video. For the price I would expect the container to be full.
We’re so glad you enjoyed the seasoning and that it worked well on your Tri-Tip! Regarding the fill level, we fill each tin to the designated fill weight listed on the label rather than to the very top. The images used for marketing purposes may show a full tin, but because each seasoning has a different density, the volume may vary while still meeting the correct weight. We truly appreciate your support and feedback—thank you for being a valued customer!
I just received another order, but I only ordered ONE. Please refund me for the second shipment. Thank you.
We apologize for the mix-up with your order. Our team has reached out to you to resolve this. Let us know if there's anything else we can do! Thank you for bringing this to our attention and we hope you enjoy your seasoning set.
Lid came off while inside box and spice all over the place.
We’re so sorry to hear about the issue with your order. Our team will be in touch with you to make this right. We truly appreciate your support and look forward to resolving this for you.